In Defense Of Mr. Universe

I’m going to quote at length here from one part of this Cracked article about Jews in science fiction movies. Specifically, where it addresses the character of Mr. Universe from the movie Serenity.

Mr. Universe is the ultimate tech geek, and he lives alone on a moon. Oh wait, not alone. He’s married to a robot wife, because clearly he’s less than a man. Oh, and how do we know he’s Jewish? Well, for one, he’s portrayed by David Krumholtz.

The second bit of evidence is that we’re shown footage of Mr. Universe’s wedding, where he wears a yarmulke and breaks a glass as per Jewish tradition. Oh, and he exhibits that classic Firefly Jewish trait — he caves under pressure instantly. Yep, Mr. Universe bends over for “The Operative” faster than Whedon can remove his female protagonist’s shoes. Is that racist? No. Is it awful? No. But it’s just weird that two characters who cave under evil are revealed to be Jews, even though their religion is completely irrelevant to the plot.

Here’s the thing: This actually is not what happens in Serenity, and actually not what Mr. Universe does.

Rather, surrounded by Alliance forces and held at sword-point by the Operative, Mr. Universe plays the part of caver, or betrayer, but in reality tips off Mal and his crew to the fact that the Alliance already awaits them at his moon-based communications complex.

What he does, specifically, is say this to Mal.

Bring it on bring it on bring it on! From here to the eyes and ears of the ‘verse, that’s my motto, or it might be if I start having a motto.

You’re gonna get caught in the ion cloud, it’ll play merry hob with your radar, but pretty pretty lights and a few miles after you’ll be right in my orbit.

So what?

Well, to begin with, Mr. Universe does have a motto, as established earlier in the movie: “You can’t stop the signal.” Pretending he doesn’t have a motto, and then rephrasing the one he has in an awkward and clumsy fashion is Mr. Universe’s signal (no pun) to Mal and his crew that something’s wrong, that they’re flying into a trap. Going out of his way to mention how the ion cloud will interfere with their radar just reinforces the warning. Paraphrasing: “Mal, you won’t be able to see all these ships waiting for you.”

What’s more, once Mal succeeds in reaching the now-dead Mr. Universe, his lovebot Lenore plays a recorded message for Mal, one in which Mr. Universe explains that there’s a backup transmitter undiscovered by the Operative and his Alliance troops.

On the surface, Mr. Universe does what the Operative demands, but in reality and underneath, he does precisely and deliberately the opposite. He warns the crew, and tells them how to succeed in their mission, all without the Operative or the Alliance knowing he’s doing it.

Mr. Universe in fact is single-handedly responsible for warning Mal and the crew of Serenity of the dangers ahead of them. Nowhere in the ‘verse would that be considered caving under the pressure of evil.

It’s why he deserves that honored place beside Shepherd Derrial Book and Hoban “Wash” Washburne.

Postscripts

  • After sending this message, Mr. Universe turns to the Operative and decidedly compares himself to Judas, but this isn’t because he betrayed the crew. It’s because he needs the Operative to believe he has.
  • Mr. Universe, through these warnings to Mal, in fact is the living embodiment of his actual motto. Even under duress and threat, his coded signal to the crew will not be stopped.
  • In case anyone hadn’t remembered that Mr. Universe in fact did have a motto, it’s repeated again — twice, actually — in his recorded message to Mal via Lenore.

Postscripts 2

  • It occurs to me only later that, oddly, this all is relevant to a short Serenity comic I once outlined, intended for the dormant Serenity Tales fan site but never produced.

Obama Backs Equality But Also The Right To Deny It

To be clear, I don’t want to dismiss or ignore the rhetorical importance of a sitting President of the United States expressing his personal support for marriage equality. I have to tell you that over the course of several years as I have talked to friends and family and neighbors when I think about members [...]

The Avengers’ Rebel Spirit

Whatever the final opening weekend take for The Avengers, nearly $25.00 of it will be my four viewings. It wasn’t until my third that I consciously noticed the movie’s narrative theme. But to get there, let’s double back to the now-infamous A. O. Scott review in The New York Times. “I aim to misbehave,” Malcolm [...]

Brands And Social Value On GetGlue

This morning I went on something of a rolling Twitter rant about brand use of cultural product check-in service GetGlue, prompted mostly by the incessant use of the site by Marvel to provide stickers for The Avengers, which isn’t even out yet and therefore can’t actually be watched by anyone checking-in. The brand thing where [...]

Dollhouse Writers Start Telling War Stories

Joss Whedon is nothing if not, in general, publicly deferential to whoever is footing the bill for his work. That’s not necessarily a bad policy to have. Back in 2008, not much in the way of public grumbling escaped the Fox lot in the early days of production on Dollhouse, when decisions were made that [...]

Fake Geeks, Poser Nerds, And A Question Of Values

I spent so much time the other day being perplexed by the idea of geeks caring about who’s cool that somehow I managed to miss something about the second verse of the song in question. Try to cop my style but I’m the real thing While you played sports, I played Magic the Gathering Never [...]

Brands: If You Don’t Care, I Don’t Care

It’s become clear to me that I have one social media pet peeve bigger perhaps than any other: brands using Facebook to automatically post to Twitter. In and of itself, it’s not a problem, as its most basic form simply tweets (I assume) the first 120 characters of a Facebook status, with a link to [...]

I Thought Geeks Didn’t Care About Cool

As the part of the launch of Felicia Day’s terrific-looking new Geek & Sundry channel for YouTube, she and The Guild premiered a new video for a song called “I’m the One That’s Cool”. Here’s a sample of the lyrics. Oh, no. Don’t pretend I didn’t see You roll your eyes at my gaming tee [...]

The American Skin Of Trayvon Martin And Miles Morales

Apparently in the wake of the Trayvon Martin shooting, Bruce Springsteen quite deliberately has been playing his song “American Skin (41 Shots)” on his current tour, including this stop on Florida on March 23, well worth watching. Springsteen first performed the song back in 2000, having written it about the police shooting death of Amadou [...]

Going Back: My Long-Lost Lost Finale Response

Someone I know online just finished watching all of Lost for the first time, and it reminds me that I’ve never gotten around to posting my own response to the series finale as I’d always meant to do. Thing is, my issues with the finale never were the ones everyone seemed to go on about. [...]